Yesterday was probably the most disappointed me and most fans have been coming out of an undefeated game. I was aware this was not going to be all that classic as everyone expected, but what was on show was so pathetically dire, it belied belief. Once again, Ferguson didn’t walk his talk. Once again, he played players out of position. Once again in European away games, we didn’t play to our strengths. What resulted was an utter bore fest, with us chasing shadows for most of the game. Rooney was frustrated on the wing. Ronaldo was the only outlet who the team could hardly get the ball to. Scholes and Carrick huffed and puffed and chased all game without threatening to play forward. Barcelona as expected saw all of the ball, but didn’t really penetrate that much. If anything positive came off it was the fact that we didn’t concede even after they kept the ball for almost all of the game.
Now once again, Fergie and players have come out and spun this performance as a "highly tactical" one and there are noises of “mission accomplished” coming out of the camp. Expectedly. It’s all B.S. Players and Fergie have come out and said “Now we will attack at OT”. Now being the operative word. We’ve left it late once again and I am afraid and prepared for the worst on Tuesday. It’s happened before and it’s very likely to happen again on Tuesday. Fergie risked a whole lot yesterday. He should be prepared to pay the cost.
The penalty came too early and not many players are mentally up for it in the 2nd minute You could see Ronaldo was also not too sure – the stutter was missing and he missed it. We can only guess how the game would have unfolded should he have scored. A lot of experts have come out and criticized Ronaldo once again and have made direct comparisons between Ronaldo and Messi. How can you judge Ronaldo in a game where his team had 20 odd % of possession? When everyone else played behind the ball for almost the entire game? When the likes of Rooney and Park and Tevez were wasted and hardly knew their roles? It was all down to Ferguson’s selection and tactics yesterday. I can’t fault the players for that. And given all of that, Ronaldo had a penalty, was denied at least one more clear shout and Messi didn’t trouble EVDS even once. I think Messi is a great talent, I saw Barcelona play at Nou Camp November of last year and he clearly stood out as the best player on the pitch then; but these comparisons based on one game aren’t valid as judgments on players.
Overall, this was a huge huge disappointment. How big a cost we’ll have to pay for this? Well we’ll know in 6 days. Meanwhile, it’s a trip to Stamford Bridge on Saturday, a win will clinch us the title – so as games go this is the biggest league game of the season. It seems like we’ll have to do it without Vidic. I am positive about our chances, and only a defeat will hurt our title chances. More on that coming soon.
The moment of the tie clearly was the penalty call against Brown. It was a soft call, but a penalty it was. De Rossi wasn’t up for it and from then on there was going to be just one winner. They saw more of the ball in the second half, but we dealt with it. Rio on one leg was phenomenal. Special shout out to Silvestre for doing well on his return from a long layoff.
What a moment it was to see Gaza come on! The crowd at Old Trafford extended him an amazing reception which was befitting of the occasion.
Boss revealed Rio had 3 stitches on his foot during the half time. I hope he makes it for Sunday. Carrick had a knock on his calf but should be OK. Barcelona next and to use a cliché it is the biggest test for the maturity of the squad. We’ve come through some tough games already and that will be no different. In his post match conference Boss talked about the need to be positive at Nou Camp. We’ll see if his team selection will walk his talk. I do think we have a fair chance if we have a full strength squad. The tie will have all the neutrals drooling – two quality sides that represent all that is good with the game. Both sets of fans though will be reasonably nervous. However, contrast this to the other semi finalists – Chelski and the Scousers – two teams who can pretty much bore an audience to death on their best days!
On to Arse on Sunday, we should be favorites on form but that tag has often proved tricky. We need to be ruthless in front of the goal and make all our chances count. Arsenal will play like they have nothing to lose, so it should be an interesting game. Today’s performances will make the team selection a headache for Fergie, but it’s a good position to be in. More thoughts on Arse coming up.
We’ve got one foot in the semi final, and to get through we have to approach the game in the right fashion and go and win it. The result in Rome is not a pass into the semi final. We achieved that because we worked our socks off, the team discipline was excellent and tactically we were good. That’s the kind of performance we need on Wednesday, because it’s not an absolute certainty that we'll go through.It is quite evident that we will line up with Rooney up front and I think Anderson, Carrick and Hargreaves will start. Nani may have a role to play if he is fit in time for the game. Park has done well in the last two apperances. So Ronaldo and Park with Rooney up front seems to be what Fergie will go with. Selection of the back four will really be interesting - If Rio doesn't pass the medical, than there is only Brown and Pique as potential centre backs. If he does, then I think Fergie will stick with Brown and Rio in the middle, not Pique.
AS Roma 0 2 Manchester United
Stadio Olimpico, 04.01.2008
The performance wasn't breathtaking. It wasn't fluent. It was effective. It was functional. And it gives United the vital edge going into the return leg at Old Trafford.
You can always bet that Fergie's team selection will spring a surprise on you - but even then you wouldn't have expected to see Park to start on that team sheet. A true "WTF" moment before the start. No Tevez either confirming my suspicion that it's going to be another very cautious performance - nothing like the 4-0 demolition of Villa just a few days back. And so it was - United happy to play at walking pace. We started well with keeping possession without really threatening them. But as it often happens, the home team settled soon and started to shade possession. For a while there things were quite dire. United happy to chase shadows while Roma not really doing anything of note. We had the likes of Rooney behind the ball every time they had possession. I don't agree with it, but it did deliver today.
It was Ronaldo's amazing courage that gave us the lead. Scholes' perfect floated ball saw Ronaldo leap up ahead of the defender and head it in - a jump that would have made Michael Jordan proud! He did hurt himself in the process and for a second the entire red world held a collective breath wondering if it was too early to celebrate that goal. It was to everyone's relief then seeing him back on his feet. That goal really rattled Roma and their fans. They started brightly in the second half but couldn't really make any of the chances count with EVDS making a couple of brilliant saves to keep us ahead. Rooney's goal off a fumble made it easy and from then on Roma had no belief of getting anything out of the game. Ronaldo, Carrick and Rooney all missed easy chances to make it three and virtually seal the tie. But 2-0 is a great away result - although to some level the scoreline does flatter the performance we put out there today. Some may say this was a perfect away European display or that it was a tactical masterpiece from Fergie. I am not entire sold on that yet. Will it work with a more attack minded side (uh, like Barcelona?)?
Vidic's injury around the 30 minute mark was something that spoilt the victory today. This team has some interchangeable parts - but Rio and Vidic are not one of those. We need them both fit for every game we play from now on. But its likely now that Vidic will miss games - it's just a matter of how many. I don't think we can cope without him for the rest of the season. O'shea came in today and did the job but it will be another thing to try and fit in the role for the remaining games - both in the league and in the CL. I am eagerly waiting the news on Vidic's scan.
The boss did admit that we got the breaks today:
It was a marvellous result for us. We showed discipline and composure on the ball.Ronaldo's goal changed the game for us. It was a fantastic header. His spring and courage to go in front of the defender surprised the Roma player.It was a centre-forward's header - it reminded me of myself. I thought Roma had some good chances the first 15 minutes of the second half. But there are breaks in a football match and I think they were with us today.
Man of the Match : Tough one between Ronaldo and EVDS. Ronaldo shades it just.
Moment of the Match: EVDS's early second half save from a header at 1-0 that kept the lead intact.
Moan of the Match: Undoubtedly the injury suffered by Vidic.This could cost us the title and the CL. Such cruel similarity with the happenings of last season. [ Anderson's performance today was the runner up]
Focus is back on the bread and butter league this weekend. Thoughts on that when I get a chance to catch my breath.
When the draw for the final stages of the Champions League
was made, many people made the assumption that Barca V United is an inevitable
conclusion for the semi finals. Whereas the matchup will make any football fan drool,
I think both teams have much work pending to make that happen. Any opinions on
Man United V Roma are always biased by the 7-1 drubbing we game them last year.
Although that was the most dominant European display by any team in recent
times– such destruction of a top team is one-off and just can’t be repeated
year after year. Roma are way better than that. We did play them twice earlier
in the group stages and as you would imagine, those games didn’t produce the
magic of 7-1; nor were Roma unrealistic as to get carried away by calls for “revenge”.
Both games were rather cagey affairs. I don’t expect any different on Tuesday.
The big news ahead of the game sadly is the potential injury list on both teams. Reports today suggest that Totti is a major doubt for the game, suffering a knock in the draw against Cagliari. United have some troubles of their own – Evra, Carrick and Rio are nursing knocks and EVDS seems certain to miss the trip with a groin injury. Off the three, Rio’s would be the biggest loss and the one we can’t afford to happen. We lost the plot against Milan last season in identical fashion when our central defensive partnership was broken ahead of the home game. On form, we should take care of Roma but its small breaks like these that we need to go in our favor.
A big factor as always will be Fergie’s team selection. We’ve
seen how he has been so utterly reluctant in going gung-ho in away games in
Europe. I think we are at our best when we play 4-4-2 with two strikers up
front and not the 4-5-1 [or 4-4-1-1] crap that he so often employs in away
games. The fact that he played Ronaldo, Rooney and Tevez for full 90 minutes
even after we were 3-0 up at the weekend has me suspecting that he will go with
just one of Rooney or Tevez up front. That is obviously not very positive. He
didn’t even play 2 strikers up front against Lyon in a home game – so this does
look like a Rooney up front all alone kinda day in the making. Keeping a clean
sheet should be a goal on Tuesday, but as we’ve often seen in the past, it’s
the away goal that is most vital. Apart from its obvious value, the away goal
does 2 good things for you – A) It puts a lot of pressure on the conceding team
in the reverse fixture and B) It ensures the away team comes to play and makes
sure that the game opens up at some point. That can only help us when the two
teams meet again at Old Trafford. Will we get a goal in Rome if we go out with
Rooney up front all alone? We can but that will be going about it the difficult
way. Fergie has talked about how this is the strongest squad he has had – which
is an enormous compliment but I am not sure if he actually meant it or if it
was a ploy to give the lads some confidence. It’s time now for Fergie to put
his money where his mouth is. Play
4-4-2, let the boys have a go and play like they like to do. We have quality
all over the park – I can only imagine what Rooney, Tevez and Ronaldo can do when
supported by Giggs /Scholes/Carrick/Nani. We’ve seen it in the league – now it’s
time to unleash them in Europe. Wishful thinking I know, but a fan can dream. I
know we’ve been bitten by the gung ho approach in Europe in the past [think
Madrid, Porto]; and that since then Fergie has been extremely cautious for fear
of being called tactically naïve. At the same time, this team is the strongest
we’ve had post the class of 99. I’ve heard arguments how it was the 4-5-1 that
produced the 4-0 destruction of Arsenal recently, but how many times have we
scored 3 or more with a 4-5-1? So my message clearly is to play Rooney and
Tevez up front right from the start.
The other dilemma facing Fergie would the selection of the midfield. Should he stick with Scholes and Carrick in the middle? Or will he be more cautious and pick Hargreaves? Obviously if he goes with 4-5-1 then I think it will be all three. Since Scholes played the full game on Satuday, maybe Anderson will come in from the start? This is surely a great dilemma to have – our midfield situation is the best I can ever remember – certainly the best in the post Keano phase. Remember the times when our answer used to be Fletcher? So glad that dull phase is over! I am really looking forward to the game on Tuesday. I hope the lads are up for it as this is really THE time when men are separated from the boys.
Go United!
All the best to all the reds making the difficult trip to Rome. I salute your courage given the events of last year - be Safe!
Recent Comments